Too Good To Be True Consignment's banner image.
The item "oshkosh splash pants new" is no longer available. Please browse our other items below.

Welcome to our Online Store!

Thanks for shopping at TGTBT Online.  Our Consignors thank you too!

We specialize in selling quality, gently used children's and maternity apparel, baby equipment, toys, books, DVDs, baby accessories and so much more.  Due to the nature of consignment, all sales are Final.

Our store location at 141 Torbay Road is OPEN!!  Covid-19 restrictions are in place so please wear a mask, social distance, and stay home if you feel unwell. Follow our Facebook page for the most up-to-date store information at  

For all details related to Drop-Offs, and to Book an Appointment, please use the "Consign With Us" tab above.


Shopping Online:

For items listed on this site for sale, please choose "Pick-Up in Store" for Curbside Pick-Up and Free Local Delivery on purchases of $25 or more.  You will then receive an email with the details.

Shipping will be based on the toal of each purchase, such as:

$0.01 to $9.99 = $6.99

$10.00 to $29.99 = $12.99

$30.00 to $74.99 = $15.99

$75.00 and up = FREE

Thanks again for your support of our local business!  Stay Safe & Be Kind!


Evenflo Exersaucer

Evenflo Exersaucer Learn More

Baby Trend Sit/stand

Baby Trend Sit/stand, grey canopy, little more loved. Learn More

Little Tikes Tool Bench

Little Tikes Tool Bench, None, Size: None Learn More

Brown Wooden Crib

Brown Wooden Crib, few scratches, no matress. Learn More

Baby Trend Sit N Stand

Baby Trend Sit N Stand, black canopy, EUC Learn More

Farm Excersaucer

Farm Excersaucer, None, Size: None Learn More

FP Tub/sling

FP Tub/sling, Green, Size: None Learn More

FP Tub/sling

FP Tub/sling, Green, Size: None Learn More

Giraffe Nursery Set
Size: OS
$49.99 $59.99 (save 17%)

Giraffe Nursery Set, Yellow, Size: OS Learn More

Shopping Cart Cover

Shopping Cart Cover, Red, Size: None Learn More

FP Tub/Sling

FP Tub/Sling, Green, Size: None Learn More

UA Hoodie
Size: 10/12yrs

UA Hoodie, Grey, Size: 10/12yrs Learn More