Too Good To Be True Consignment's banner image.

Welcome to our Online Store!

Thanks for shopping at TGTBT Online.  Our Consignors thank you too!

We specialize in selling quality, gently used children's and maternity apparel, baby equipment, toys, books, DVDs, baby accessories and so much more.  Due to the nature of consignment, all sales are Final.

Our store location at 141 Torbay Road, inside the Torbay Road Mall, is now OPEN during most days of the week, with the most up-to-date store information available on our Facebook page at  We are pleased to offer some items through this site as either Ship-To-Me, Curbside Pick-Up and Free Local Delivery on purchases of $25 and more.

Please choose "Pick-Up in Store" for Curbside Pick-Up and Free Local Delivery on purchases of $25 or more.  You will then receive an email with the details.

Shipping will be $10 per order, with FREE shipping on orders of $75 and more.

We have carefully inspected each item that is listed for sale and each item is evaulated based on the following criteria:

New With Tags = Never been used, Original Tags still attached.

Excellent = In excellent condition.  Shows very little signs of use or like-new condition.  

Good = In very good condition.  Shows some signs of use.   

Fair = In fair condition.  Definitely been loved before with some signs of wear and use.  

Thanks again for your support of our local business!  



Due to limitations related to COVID, we will be schedulding all drop-offs at specific times and days. You will only be permitted to drop off your items durning a schedulded time. To Book a date and time please use the link below:

Updated Drop-off Information as of December 3rd, 2020:

Items to Be Dropped-Off By Appointment Only:

-        Toys and Games (Maximum of 10, must have working batteries and all necessary pieces)

-        Books (Maximum of 20)

-        Children’s Winter Outerwear (Sizes NB – 10/12) Including Waterproof Hats & Mittens

-        Children’s Winter Footwear (Sizes NB – Youth 5/6)

-        Brand Name Hoodies and Sweaters (No Long Sleeve Shirts or T-Shirts) (Maximum of 10)

-        Brand Name Athletic Pants, Joggers, Leggings and Jeggings (No Jeans, Cords or Dress Pants) (Maximum of 10)

-        Sleepers and PJ’s (Sizes NB – 10/12), in all Brand Names (Maximum of 20)

-        Dance & Gymnastics (Leotards, Tights & Footwear)

-        Children’s Swimwear (Sizes NB – 10/12)


Items that can be Dropped-Off at Anytime (without Appointment):


-        Maternity and Nursing Clothing and Accessories (No Summer Items)

-        Pregnancy and Childcare books

-        Baby items (both large and small) such as swings, bouncey chairs, change tables, highchairs, booster seats, diaper genies, bottle warmers, sleepsacs, etc. (No baby clothing)

-        Children’s skates (Including Bob Skates) up to Youth Size 5.

-        Skating Aids (No skating helmets unless New with Tags attached)


Note: We are no longer accepting any Christmas Items for this year.

No products found.

No products found.