Maggie's Closet's banner image.

Welcome to our Online Store!

Maggie's Closet is one of the largest consignment shops in southeastern Wisconsin with two floors of amazing items. The main floor is junior, misses, women's, petite and plus size clothing. We carry fashions from casual to black tie. No outfit is complete without the right purse, shoes, jewelry and accessories so, don't worry, we have those items, too!

The lower level is a treasure trove of home decor, furniture, pictures, throw pillows and more! We carry unique pieces from your home, both antique and brand new! Our 50% off clothing and decor section is also located in the lower level.

New items arrive daily so stop back often. Shop the consignment shop that feels like a boutique!

$189.99 $249.99 (save 24%)
$49.99 $64.99 (save 23%)
Womens Clothing
2 Pc MOB Long Dress
Size: 12
$69.99
Home Decor
Throw Pillow
Size: Medium
$8.99
Home Decor
Throw Pillow
Size: Large
$9.99
Home Decor
Vino Picture
Size: 21 In. Squ
$17.99
Home Decor
Painted Mirror W/violets
Size: 24x28
$24.99 $29.99 (save 17%)
Womens Clothing
Alex 2 Pc MOB Dress
Size: 8
$89.99
Home Decor
Thow Pillow W/shell
Size: Medium
$8.99
Home Decor
Grape Vine Picture
Size: Tall
$38.99
Prom
Windsor Bead Prom
Size: 5
$89.99 $116.99 (save 23%)
$129.99 $224.99 (save 42%)
Rachel Allen 2 Pc Floral
Size: 14
$189.99 $249.99 (save 24%)

Rachel Allen 2 piece formal with lace and beaded back zip top and beatiful floral skirt that is longer in the back Mint, pink, yellow, green and red Size: 14 REMINDER: There are no returns so you may want to stop in and try it on before purchasing Learn More

City Triangle Long Prom
Size: 5
$49.99 $64.99 (save 23%)

City Triangle Long Prom Beaded straps and empire waist Black Size: 5 NO RETURNS ON PROM DRESSES Learn More

2 Pc MOB Long Dress
Size: 12
$69.99

This beautiful two piece long formal would be a wonderful mother of the bride/groom dress. The sheer jacket has beading that matches the bottom of the dress. The fabric content tag has been removed but it's likely 100% polyester NO RETURNS. If you are uncertain of size, please stop in and try it on. Eggplant Size: 12 Learn More

Throw Pillow
Size: Medium
$8.99

Throw Pillow, Burnt Or, Size: Medium Learn More

Throw Pillow
Size: Large
$9.99

Throw Pillow, Teal/brn Size: Large Learn More

Vino Picture
Size: 21 In. Squ
$17.99

Vino Picture, Red/tan, Size: 21 In. Squ Learn More

Painted Mirror W/violets
Size: 24x28
$24.99 $29.99 (save 17%)

Farmhouse painted mirror. Size: 29x24 White, purple, green IN STORE PICK UP ONLY Learn More

Alex 2 Pc MOB Dress
Size: 8
$89.99

Alex Nights 2 piece long formal. The cropped bolero jacket has beautiful beading arount the neckline. The dress is spaghetti strap with a back zip closure. Freshly dry cleaned 100% polyester NO RETURNS; we strongly suggest you stop in and try it on if you're unsure of your size. Champagne Size: 8 Learn More

Thow Pillow W/shell
Size: Medium
$8.99

White and tan shell throw pillow One of 2 (see #89903) Learn More

Grape Vine Picture
Size: Tall
$38.99

Grape Vine Picture Green, red, cream Size: 41 x 20,5 Learn More

Windsor Bead Prom
Size: 5
$89.99 $116.99 (save 23%)

NEW Windsor straight prom dress with beaded bodice. Padded cups, back zip closure and adjustable shoulder straps. High front slit Hot Pink Size: 5 NO RETURNS ON PROM DRESSES! Learn More

Sterling Sparkly Prom Dr
Size: 4
$129.99 $224.99 (save 42%)

Sterling Sparkly Sheath Formal Side slit skirt and back zip closure Black and gold Size: 4 Learn More

Pages: