Maggie's Closet's banner image.

Welcome to our Online Store!

Maggie's Closet is one of the largest consignment shops in southeastern Wisconsin with two floors of amazing items. The main floor is junior, misses, women's, petite and plus size clothing. We carry fashions from casual to black tie. No outfit is complete without the right purse, shoes, jewelry and accessories so, don't worry, we have those items, too!

The lower level is a treasure trove of home decor, furniture, pictures, throw pillows and more! We carry unique pieces from your home, both antique and brand new! Our 50% off clothing and decor section is also located in the lower level.

New items arrive daily so stop back often. Shop the consignment shop that feels like a boutique!

Home Decor
Pottery Barn Seville Scon
Size: 9.5 X 3.5d
$9.99
Junior
NEW Endless Rose Dress
Size: Small
$19.99
Home Decor
Hydrangea W/butterfly
Size: 13x16
$12.99
Prom
Birrin Long Formal
Size: Small
$99.99
Prom
Emerald Sundae Sequin
Size: Medium
$169.99
$189.99 $249.99 (save 24%)
$49.99 $64.99 (save 23%)
Junior
PHS Danceline Zip Up
Size: Medium
$8.99
Pottery Barn Seville Scon
Size: 9.5 X 3.5d
$9.99

Pottery Barn wall candle holder (See item 119343 if you want 2!) Size: 9.5 long X 3.5deep Learn More

NEW Endless Rose Dress
Size: Small
$19.99

New with tags dress with front cutout, industrial back zipper, fully lined. Poly/spandex blend Learn More

Aiden Mattox Emb Top
Size: 6
$199.99

Aiden Mattox strapless formal with embellished applique top. Strapless with back zip closure. Full satin skirt with POCKETS! Black and cream Size: 6 NO RETURNS ON PROM DRESSES! Learn More

Fiesta Royal Formal W/emb
Size: Medium
$139.99

Fiesta long formal with embroidered and beaded flower and ivy pattern. Lightly padded cups, asymetrical hemline over sheer, embroidered mesh Side zip closure Royal and silver Size: Medium REMEMBER: There are no returns so we suggest you stop in and try it on Learn More

Betsy Adams Lace W/gem
$159.99

Betsy Adams Lace Formal Beautifully gemmed with a detachable gem belt. Built in cups, open back and back zip closure. Slightly longer back Black Size: 0 Learn More

Hydrangea W/butterfly
Size: 13x16
$12.99

Hydrangea with butterfly picture Size: 13x16 Learn More

Birrin Long Formal
Size: Small
$99.99

Birrin Long Formal Delicate rose detail on the straps and fringe neckline 100% Polyester Red Size: Small NO RETURNS ON PROM DRESSES Learn More

NEW Teeze Me Long Prom
Size: 1
$179.99

NEW Teeze Me Long Prom Gown Black fully lined gem crusted corset bodice, flowy net bottom. Black satin ribbon belt, strapless Size: 1 Learn More

Emerald Sundae Sequin
Size: Medium
$169.99

Emerald Sundae sequin gown Nylon exterior and stretchy polyester lining for a curve hugging fit. Back zip closure Gold Size: Medium Learn More

Rachel Allen 2 Pc Floral
Size: 14
$189.99 $249.99 (save 24%)

Rachel Allen 2 piece formal with lace and beaded back zip top and beatiful floral skirt that is longer in the back Mint, pink, yellow, green and red Size: 14 REMINDER: There are no returns so you may want to stop in and try it on before purchasing Learn More

City Triangle Long Prom
Size: 5
$49.99 $64.99 (save 23%)

City Triangle Long Prom Beaded straps and empire waist Black Size: 5 NO RETURNS ON PROM DRESSES Learn More

PHS Danceline Zip Up
Size: Medium
$8.99

PHS Danceline Zip Up Black, orange and white Size: Medium Learn More

Pages: