A.T. Stewart Exchange's banner image.

Welcome to our Online Store!

The A.T. Stewart Exchange is the Consignment Shop of The Garden City Historical Society, a non-profit organization founded in 1975.

The Exchange is staffed by volunteers, and is located on the lower level, in the rear of The Garden City Historical Society Museum.

Proceeds from the Exchange benefit The Garden City Historical Society, helping to defray the costs of programs and events, as well as maintenance and repairs to the Museum, an 1872 structure built at the time of Garden City’s founding.

Volunteers are always welcome!

Svc. For 8 Savoy China

Svc. For 8 Savoy Home Chi, Wh/pk/go, Size: None Learn More

Childs Rush Rocking Chair
$20.00 $40.00 (save 50%)

Childs Rocking Chair Rush, None, Size: None Learn More

Noritake Svc. For 12 Asia

Noritake Svc. For 12 Asia, Floral (extra pieces, plus creamer & sugar, veggie dishes, platter and gravy boat). Valued at $500 Learn More

10 Waterford Champagne
$100.00 $225.00 (save 56%)

10 Waterford Champagne, None, Size: None Learn More

Set Of 6 Green Tapers
Size: 10\"

Set Of 6 Tapers, Green, Size: 10\" Learn More

Lucky Bug Carrysome
Size: Any

\"Lucky\" Bearington Bears Ladybug Carrysome (small) Learn More

Montauk Lighthouse Orname
Size: 2.5\"

Montauk Lighthouse Orname, Multi, Size: 2.5\" (glass) Learn More

Painted Firescreen

Painted Firescreen Learn More

Pr. Tapestry Pulls

Pr. Tapestry Pulls Learn More

5 Lead Crystal Goblets
Size: Med

5 Lead Crystal Goblets, Multi, Size: Med Learn More

Cameo Glass Etched Vase
Size: 12\"

Cameo Glass Etched Vase, White, Size: 12\" Learn More

Chinese Celadon Crane Vas
Size: 12\"

Chinese Celadon Crane Vas, Green, Size: 12\" Learn More