Welcome to our Online Store!

The A.T. Stewart Exchange is the Consignment Shop of The Garden City Historical Society, a non-profit organization founded in 1975.

The Exchange is staffed by volunteers, and is located on the lower level, in the rear of The Garden City Historical Society Museum.

Proceeds from the Exchange benefit The Garden City Historical Society, helping to defray the costs of programs and events, as well as maintenance and repairs to the Museum, an 1872 structure built at the time of Garden City’s founding.

Volunteers are always welcome!

just arrived
Jewelry
Turquoise Coral Necklace
Size: Choker
$69.00
just arrived
Silver
Powell S/P Vintage Caviar
Size: 8" Wide
$100.00
NY Show Items
Baggu Zebra Bag
Size: Any
$12.00
NY Show Items
Baggu Lime Bag
Size: Any
$12.00
NY Show Items
Baggu Aloe Bag
Size: Any
$12.00
NY Show Items
Baggu Sailor Stripe Bag
Size: Any
$12.00
NY Show Items
Anchor Baseball Cap
Size: Small
$10.00
NY Show Items
Anchor Canvas Bag
Size: 17"
$15.00
NY Show Items
Navy Straw Hat
$18.00
Turquoise Coral Necklace
Size: Choker
$69.00

Turquoise Coral Necklace, Chunky, Blue & red, Size: Choker (10" at longest point) Learn More

Powell S/P Vintage Caviar
Size: 8" Wide
$100.00

Powell S/P Vintage Caviar, Silver, Size: 8" Wide x 4" deep with glass dish insert. (as seen on EBay $228) Learn More

Vintage G. Schneider Selt
Size: 11"
$35.00

Vintage G. Schneider Seltzer Bottle, Clear, Size: 11" Learn More

Sterling Opal Bracelet
Size: 6"
$80.00

Sterling Opal Bracelet, Opal, Size: 6" Learn More

Sterling Onyx & Opal Brac
Size: 7"
$80.00

Sterling Onyx & Opal Brac, Multi, Size: 7" Learn More

Baggu Zebra Bag
Size: Any
$12.00

Baggu Zebra Bag, Yel/bl, Size: folds into 4" sac Learn More

Baggu Lime Bag
Size: Any
$12.00

Baggu Lime Bag, Green, Size: folds into 4" sac Learn More

Baggu Aloe Bag
Size: Any
$12.00

Baggu Aloe Bag, Green, Size: folds into 4" sac Learn More

Baggu Sailor Stripe Bag
Size: Any
$12.00

Baggu Sailor Stripe Bag, Wh/bl, Size: folds into 4" sac Learn More

Anchor Baseball Cap
Size: Small
$10.00

Anchor Baseball Cap, White, Size: Small Learn More

Anchor Canvas Bag
Size: 17"
$15.00

Anchor Canvas Bag, None, Size: 17" Learn More

Navy Straw Hat
$18.00

Navy Straw Hat (also comes in pink, beige & grey) Learn More

Pages: